The Bombay High Court rejected the bail plea of Salim Sheikh, an accused in the Baba Siddiqui murder case. Siddiqui, a local Shiv Sena leader, was shot dead in Kurla on March 26, 2024.
Sheikh was accused of aiding and abetting the shooters, Mohammad Aslam and Mohammad Arif, by providing them with information about Siddiqui’s movements and a safe passage after the crime. The prosecution argued Sheikh was a key conspirator and his involvement was evidenced by call data records showing communication with the shooters before and after the murder. They also presented witness testimonies implicating him.
Sheikh’s lawyers contended he was falsely implicated and had no prior criminal record. They argued the evidence against him was circumstantial and lacked direct proof of his involvement in the planning or execution of the murder. They also highlighted his permanent residence in Mumbai and assured his cooperation with the investigation.
However, Justice N. J. Jamadar dismissed the bail application, observing that the evidence presented by the prosecution, particularly the call data records and witness statements, indicated Sheikh’s active role in the conspiracy. The court noted the seriousness of the offence and the potential for Sheikh to tamper with evidence or influence witnesses if released on bail.
The court emphasized that the investigation revealed a pre-planned attack and Sheikh’s alleged knowledge of the target and post-crime arrangements suggested a deliberate involvement. It found sufficient grounds to believe Sheikh was connected to the crime and his release would be detrimental to the investigation.
The court stated that the evidence collected so far requires further investigation and Sheikh’s continued detention is necessary to ensure a fair trial and prevent any potential obstruction of justice. The bail plea was therefore rejected, and Sheikh will remain in judicial custody.
